history of marino estate, dublin 3 – architecture and design influences
Above: Marino estate under construction
The history of the Marino estate in Dublin is of interest being the first inter-war housing development in Ireland to be influenced by the then new “garden suburbs” ideas encapsulated in the Tudor Walters Report in the UK and it’s Irish counterpart, PC Cowan’s 1918 Report on Dublin Housing. This article looks at the design influences that shaped the Marino estate – for more reading on the history and background to the estate, see the reference books below.
The garden suburb ideas which were developing among architects at the time proposed large formally-planned suburban estates at moderate densities (typically 12 houses per acre), with substantial areas of open space in contrast to the formal Victorian streets that had served as a development model up to them.
The historical evolution of the Marino layout is summarised in the maps above which illustrate the site before and after it’s development and the early schemes of the design in development by the architects.
Marino was heavily influenced by the early garden suburb estates in England. The similarities to estates at Roehampton (now called Doverhouse Road estate) and Becontree in London are particularly striking as illustrated below. The geometric open spaces, crescents, stepped terraces of 4-8 houses, and canted blocks that highlight crossroad nodes in the London schemes (bottom row) were adopted in the Marino layout (top row). The “celtic cross” symbol is sometimes cited as an influence on the Marino layout, however it can be seen that the motif was already used in Becontree. The use of radial layouts in the London schemes apparently causes as much confusion as it does in Dublin today!
The Marino house designs also adapted similar forms and materials to their London counterparts. The houses and sites are of similar dimensions and laid out with front & rear gardens which was an innovation at the time. Two-storey houses feature red terracotta roof tiles or slate finish in both instances with a mixture of brick or render finishes. The dormer mansard-style houses which are associated with Marino also feature in London although with a straight roof profile.
Dublin, 1910-1940 Shaping the City and Suburbs – Ruth McManus
John Bull’s Other Homes (State Housing and British Policy in Ireland 1883 – 1922) – Murray Fraser
Hi Fergal, really interesting.
I watched something on ‘memes’ and ‘temes’ on TED Talks last night and you can clearly see the Garden City meme taking flight in the 20s as seen in Marino, Dublin.
The garden city concept was different to the garden suburb model. Ebeneezer Howard who originally proposed the garden city model did not support suburbanisation – he saw his model of self-contained satellite communities as the solution to it.
Interesting related article:
Thanks Brendan. They’re a key part of the character of these building and it’s important that the methods of construction are conserved where possible.
[…] The evolution of 20th century windows is illustrated in Marino. The extracts from photographs from the Dublin City Archive in the slideshow above illustrate the window patterns from the time it was built (for more on the planning history of the estate see here). […]
[…] A large element of the character of Marino comes from it’s varied and unique roof lines. A variety of roofing materials were used which emulated the style of estates at Roehampton and Becontree, London which clearly influenced the Dublin City Council architects at the time (for more details see here). […]